Skip to content

Which Pizza Is Better, Grimaldi’s or Juliana’s?

You’ll find two iconic pizzerias in the trendy DUMBO section of Brooklyn. As you know, I’m always recommending a visit to DUMBO, both here and on Instagram, so of course I have to help you find a place to eat while you’re there.

The two pizzerias are Grimaldi’s and Juliana’s. We’ve eaten at both so here’s our review of which one you should choose.

How Popular Are Grimaldi’s and Juliana’s?

You’ll have to stand in line, outside, to be seated at either one. The wait can be long, too. Our last visit to Juliana’s was in January, a slow month, and we waited 45 minutes. Juliana’s is rated number one on TripAdvisor, Yelp and Zagat’s.

Grimaldi’s

Grimaldi’s is cash-only. The employees are very friendly and hard-working. We were there last on a hot day in September and we were lead to a table upstairs. It was very hot and we asked for another table. The employees understood completely and were happy to give us the very next table downstairs where it was much cooler.

Grimaldi’s or Juliana’s: Our Pick
We ordered a simple margarita pie and waited about 25 minutes for it. This was perfect since it gave us time to relax and talk.

When the pizza came, it was absolutely delicious. We ate the entire pie ourselves and then left full and happy.

Juliana’s

So who is the owner of Juliana’s? Pasquale Grimaldi, the founder of Grimaldi’s Pizzeria. In 2011, Pasquale Grimaldi sold his pizzeria, along with the iconic name. The following year, when he and his wife, Carmella, decided to re-enter the business, they no longer had the rights to their own last name. Juliana was Paquale’s mother.

Juliana’s homemade mozzarella cheese
We ordered a specialty pizza this time: cherry tomato, bufala mozzarella, garlic and sea salt.

Juliana’s dining room is small. As we waited outside, we saw more and more people leaving the restaurant but no one else was being seated. The sign outside said they were “stoking the coal oven and would re-open soon… whatever that meant. Once the restaurant was empty, they let everyone in and people headed straight to whatever tables they could find. Like musical chairs, we were almost left standing, but we realized this was a free-for-all and grabbed a table. It was a poor start.

The service at Juliana’s is also very friendly. We ordered wine and were happy to wait the 25 minutes for our pizza so we could relax and talk.

The pizza arrived and it was very flavorful. The mozzarella is homemade and therefore very fresh. The pizza wasn’t oily, but fresh and healthy, just like we found at Grimaldi’s and Lombardi’s in Little Italy, Manhattan (see our review).

So Which Is Better, Grimaldi’s or Juliana’s?

There was no clear winner. You will be happy at both pizzerias. Like in our previous review of the famous Lombardi’s, this pizza is less greasy and much healthier than the typical NYC pizza. It’s also more expensive.

The typical NYC pizzeria is very informal and people ask for a slice (i.e., a piece of a large pie, cut into eight sections). Some people walk with their slices and others bring them to a table. This is how almost every New Yorker eats pizza. But eat this too often, and you’ll have to shop for larger clothing.

You’ll be happy at either one, but the next time I’m in a position to choose, I will choose….. Grimaldi’s, not for the quality, but for the atmosphere.

Aixa’s Recommended Reading: Where to get off the NYC Ferry

Take #iconic NYC Photos eBook by Aixa

13 thoughts on “Which Pizza Is Better, Grimaldi’s or Juliana’s? Leave a comment

    • Yes, you would be happier at both 😋🍕 Both are healthy too and nice dining experiences (once you get off the lines)

  1. I didn’t know about Grimaldi’s selling their pizzeria name rights. Thanks for the info. Grimaldi’s is my younger son’s favorite pizza where we live and eating there has a lot of meaning for us. After his bone marrow transplant, he wasn’t allowed to eat restaurant food for 100 days. As soon as 100 days was up, he first requested to go to Grimaldi’s. 😊

    • Well that alone makes Grimaldi’s the absolute best! He had something to look forward to. I thought of you when I published this because you told me that Grimaldi’s is his favorite.

  2. Another great post, Aixa! I liked reading about the history of Juliana’s. We’ll add this to our list of things to do on our next visit. You’re going to end up planning our whole trip. Haha Eating while walking doesn’t sound appealing to me, so we’ll make sure to get a table. 🙂

    • You might be surprised because some Italian friends and family have visited and have loved NY pizza. I’ve only eaten Italian pizza in Rome and north. It was great, but I would love to try it (and other dishes) in southern Italy.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: